Thursday, May 26, 2022

Heart Control vs Gun Control


             Yesterday, America was shocked and heartbroken at the news that we had experienced yet another school shooting in Uvalde, Texas.  It appears that 21 lives were snuffed out for no apparent reason and hundreds, if not thousands, will be changed forever, and not for the better.  In the immediate wake of this tragedy, it was time for the country to be shocked and to grieve over this senseless violent act and loss of life.  I think we would all argue that it was an appropriate time for the President of The United States to address the nation in an effort to soothe the aching hearts of the country and to unite us around our shared anguish and desire to help the victims; and then came Joe Biden!

            For the first couple of minutes I thought he was going to finally deliver on his inaugural speech promise of uniting the country during this difficult moment.  He was appropriately sad and spoke of the senseless loss of life and the challenges that these families would face to overcome this personal disaster.  He then quickly shifted to a message of anger, and interestingly, not an anger at the disturbed young man who killed these children and two teachers, but an anger at his political opponents.  Before the bodies had been counted and identified, before all the facts were in, he spent most of the speech dividing the country once again along ideological lines.

It is my opinion that this anger and hatred is being constantly infused into our country’s bloodstream and is, in fact, the cause of all of the escalating violence, including school shootings, in America.  From Maxine Waters’ screaming declaration that her political opponents weren’t, “welcome here (in America) anymore” to Chuck Schumer’s threat to Supreme Court Justices to Joe Biden’s condemnation of the horse-riding border guards, our political discourse has become inappropriate, hate filled and even inaccurate.  Our politicians are teaching us that it is not OK for people to have different opinions on our country’s policies.  They are training us that we must hate and condemn and demonize anyone who differs from our thinking.  And this hatred and anger is permeating our society, including our children, with tragic results.  We need heart control way more than we need gun control.

So, now that we’ve broached the concept of gun control, let’s talk a little about the origins of the 2nd Amendment to the Constitution.  I’m not a big gun owner, but I have studied the origins and original intent of our Constitution and Bill of Rights.  The second amendment was not enumerated to protect the rights of people to hunt in 1787.  The 2nd Amendment was included in the Bill of Rights to protect “We the People” from an oppressive government which could then cancel all of our rights through brute force.

I’m not saying that there aren’t things we as a country can do to protect our schools and minimize crime and violence in our cities.  We do have some very restrictive gun laws around the country today.  Might we need more?  I don’t know, but I’m willing to listen.  How much of the $190 Billion dollars given to our schools for Covid relief has not been spent?  Could some of that be used to improve security in our schools.  I think so, and I’m willing to listen to some ideas.  The 2nd Amendment, however, is not going away no matter how much Beto O’Rourke wants to go door to door and confiscate America’s (at least Texas’) guns.  Can we do more?  Sure, but that will require both sides of this debate to LISTEN respectfully to each other and be willing to meet in the middle.

And our children seem to be under a particularly strong assault.  They are desensitized to violence and death through video games, movies and today’s music.  Schools that teach oppressor vs victim philosophies are not uniting them but turning both groups against each other.  Finally, if you study the beginnings of the explosion of school shooting deaths in America, there is a direct correlation between those shootings and America’s effort to take God out of our schools in the 1960’s. Bringing God and optional prayer and Bible study back into our public schools would certainly offer a counter balance to the violence and hate offered up by our modern-day games, movies and music. 

Let us not forget, however, the premise of this article.  We, as a country, need a change of hearts more than a change in our gun laws.  How do we do that?  First, we must change our own hearts.  We need to listen to those who disagree with us instead of condemning them immediately before we even understand their positions.  And even beyond listening, we must seek to understand.  When we do this, we will find compromise that will satisfy both sides of any disagreement.  We must avoid the temptation to condemn, hate and dehumanize.  That change alone will enrich each of our lives and unite our country around common ground and common decency.

We must also reject the purveyors of anger, hostility and disregard for others.  If it is a politician, that’s easy.  Vote them out of office.  If it is the media, which it often is, stop reading, cancel your subscription or change the channel.  They will eventually get the message and change their direction or go out of business.  We must let our political leaders and information venues know that “We the People” are in charge and we won’t take the division, disdain and fearmongering any longer. I’m praying for our country. Amen.

 

9 comments:

  1. "We must also reject the purveyors of anger, hostility and disregard for others. If it is a politician, that’s easy. Vote them out of office."

    Sorry, but no one takes this sentiment seriously from Republicans. Your actions don't match your words. You embraced too much of this:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1es9MZyyPOA

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ndpe09emTSA




    We all remember this too well:

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So you believe we need more anger, hostility and disregard of others. I'm offering a solution, and you can reject it, but you should at least offer a better one.

      Delete
    2. Not at all. I was a Republican once because it was a party of civility and manners. My solution is don't elect GOP candidates who mock the disabled, for starters. Or encourage violence and offer to pay the bills. Baby steps. #BeBest

      Delete
  2. Not even Republicans believe Republicans want unity. Your leader can't have cheers at every rally when he shouts "There is THE ENEMY!" at the media or yells "Lock her up" and then you turn around and pearl clutch about unity.

    Nor will there be unity as long as the NRA has the political power it does. Even though it's been exposed as corrupt, it still has the power to ruin most any Republican in a Republican primary. As a result, they all live in fear of the NRA. Look at our own state's Stand Your Ground debate in '21 for an example. Prosecutors didn't want it, sheriffs organizations didn't want it, but they all cowered in fear of the NRA, and so we overturned 100 years of law. Not because of an identifiable problem in Arkansas, but because Republican politicians were scared to death of a corrupt nonprofit.

    Ironically, at the NRA national convention next week, where Donald Trump, Ted Cruz, and Greg Abbott are supposed to speak, attendees are NOT PERMITTED TO CARRY A GUN. Maybe you think that's because it's in some liberal blue state full of squishy politicians? Nope, it's in Houson, Texas.

    So no, there is no bill that Republicans, especially in red states dare unify with Democrats on, no matter how modest. The best we'll get is Ted Cruz' silliness on doors or something equally inane.

    So the idea that there's going to be unity come out of this shooting, when there wasn't unity after any of the others, is silly. And arguably, that's the way it should be - our country wasn't founded by singing Kumbaya around a campfire. We were founded in arguments, disagreements, and battle with not just external foes but ourselves as well. The Founders threw as more mud at each other as any modern politicians ever thought about.

    Your criticism that Joe Biden isn't unifying us is not only ahistorical, it's not even something you really want, as evidenced by the politicians you DO support.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Again, you can knock everything, but without offering a better solution it's just bitching.

      And attacking John Wayne won't cut it either. Have you watched McClintock? Watch it. And if you think today's TV, Movies, videos, music and games are less violent than in the 70's and 80's, then you are alone. Yes, violence was depicted in old movies to make a comment on history or current conditions. Today, all of those media elements are full of gratuitous violence, and again if you can't even admit that, you are on an island by yourself.

      Delete
  3. " Bringing God and optional prayer and Bible study back into our public schools would certainly offer a counter balance to the violence and hate offered up by our modern-day games, movies and music."

    It is a myth that kids can't pray in school or study the Bible in school. They absolutely can and absolutely do.

    " Schools that teach oppressor vs victim philosophies are not uniting them but turning both groups against each other. "

    I guess we should stop teaching the Civil War, WW2, Civil Rights Era, The Great Migration of the early 1900s, The Indian Wars of the 1800s, and so on? Were we better off when no one knew about the Tulsa Race Riot of 1921? I guess some of us were, huh?

    " They are desensitized to violence and death through video games, movies and today’s music."

    Tipper Gore, is that you? I watch the Western channel, often in black and white, all the time. Shows and movies from the alleged glory years of America. Killing, rape, theft, etc. are the central part of most of these movies. In one of the greatest classics of the era, the Searchers, John Wayne wants to kill every Indian he can find because they took his niece, then rejects her because he thinks she's been raped by the Indians and now wants to stay with them.

    ReplyDelete
  4. If you think public schools accomodate prayer and bible study, again, you are delusional. Just talk to Joseph Kennedy (football coach) who was FIRED for praying by himself after a game. Public schools used to pray together to start the day, say the national anthem. Find me a single public schools that so that today. Bringing and even encouraging voluntary prayer and bible study would have a positive impact on schools. What are public schools afraid of? violated the "wall between church and state", which isn't in the Constitution and Thomas Jefferson clearly didn't intend that statement to be used to take prayer out of schools.

    And let me repeat my John Wayne comment - And attacking John Wayne won't cut it either. Have you watched McClintock? Watch it. And if you think today's TV, Movies, videos, music and games are less violent than in the 70's and 80's, then you are alone. Yes, violence was depicted in old movies to make a comment on history or current conditions. Today, all of those media elements are full of gratuitous violence, and again if you can't even admit that, you are on an island by yourself.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A student is able to pray on their own at any time. They are able to have a bible study with other students at breaks. (Obviously during class time they can't interrupt). What can't happen is school-led prayer.

      There are no public schools that start the day with prayer, nor should there be. The question would quickly become - whose prayer? I'm Catholic, would an Our Father bother me? Nope. It wouldn't be right to have a Jewish kid be required to be silent to listen to it.

      A Hail Mary wouldn't bother me, but there are many Evangelicals and Baptists who would immediately object.

      Jefferson was a deist in a time when public schools weren't even a thing. That doesn't tell me much.

      I didn't attack John Wayne. I pointed out the obvious fact that the days of yore when everything was allegedly so great in movies and music dealt with adult themes too. The 70s and 80s had their own handwringing from Tipper and those who objected to movies like Dirty Harry, Deer Hunter, etc. You think there wasn't sex and violence then? Come on. Adults have been complaining about the sex and violence in what their kids are listening to since there were kids.

      Violence was depicted in old movies because people like gunfights and fistfights. There was no larger historical point. And I love McClintock, but the great scene of the huge town fight down the mudslide wasn't making a historical comment or even one on "current conditions." I'm thinking you haven't watched the movie in awhile.

      Delete
    2. By the way, do you find the irony in alleging that teachers are grooming your kids to feel bad about themselves because of race or even worse to be sexually assaulted, but also wanting the same teachers and administrators to teach them religion?

      It's funny when you think about it.

      Delete