Wednesday, July 7, 2021

Happy Birthday, Thomas Sowell

 The View from the Middle 

Thomas Sowell is a brilliant economist, social theorist and philosopher who you might not have heard of.  He has lived an extraordinary life, rich in experiences and formal education which has given him the material to write over 30 books.  He was born on June 30th, 1930 (happy birthday, Thomas!) in Gastonia, North Carolina.  Unfortunately, his father died before his birth and because his mother already had four children, his great aunt along with her two grown daughters adopted and raised Thomas.  He was not born to privilege, but his challenging upbringing just added to the rich quiver of life trials and adventures that has formed his opinions.

At age nine they moved to Harlem, where he eventually qualified to attend the prestigious Stuyvesant High School in New York.  Unfortunately, at age 17 he was forced to withdraw from “the Stuy” for financial and family reasons.  But he didn’t turn to crime as a solution.  He got multiple jobs and even tried out for the Brooklyn Dodgers before he went into the Marines as a photographer.  After leaving the Marines he took night classes at Howard University and scored high enough on College Board exams to enter Harvard.

I won’t bore you with an extensive list of his awards and accomplishments, but let me highlight just a few to give you a sense of the significance of his life’s work.  He graduated magna cum laude from Harvard after dropping out of high school at age 17.  He received his master’s degree from Columbia and his doctorate from UCLA and has served as a faculty member at Cornell and UCLA.  As if that’s not enough, he’s a senior fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution.  He dabbled in Marxism in his early years, but he abandoned that notion in 1960 and his fellowship at Stanford is named after Milton Friedman, Nobel Prize winning, free market economist, whom he calls his mentor.  He has been an unapologetic capitalistic, libertarian ever since.  And, if he ran for President today, even at age 91, I would vote for him.  But sadly, he is too good for politics so we can best benefit from his wisdom by reading his books.

Thomas Sowell is not just a stone-cold genius, but he is a black man whose opinions are supported by more than his intellect and education.  He has lived through Jim Crow, discrimination, civil unrest and the civil rights movement, and those experiences along with his intelligence form his opinions.  I believe he is a “must read” when it comes to economics, of course, but also when he speaks out on race relations.  His books like “Black Rednecks and White Liberals”, “Discrimination and Disparity” and his “Controversial Essays” are plainly written, powerfully reasoned and, as always supported by mountains of documented facts.  

There are many, many areas where Dr. Sowell and I agree. For example, he is no fan of our public-school system, and of course neither am I.  When my two daughters were in school, my wife and I had the luxury of “school choice” and sent our girls to a private, Christian school.  Our girls have been long out of school, and I would not personally benefit from a voucher system today, so why am I such a rabid supporter of that concept?  It’s because I think it is the best thing for our children and our country.  It would make our public schools compete or die, and it would give millions of people more choices in the education of their children.  That’s a choice that I had and it’s a choice that I believe every family should have.

Thomas Sowell put it this way, “No group is more in favor of vouchers than blacks – and no one is more opposed to vouchers than Democrats…This doesn’t mean that Democrats are racist.  It is just that they need the support of the teachers’ unions and they are not going to get it if they vote for vouchers, whereas they can count on the votes of blacks regardless.”  It is the ugly truth of politics.  Politicians often make choices not in the best interests of their constituencies in order to get elected.

In his “Controversial Essays” he added that, “public schools are where the battle needs to be fought, but too many black leaders are too dependent on labor unions in general and teachers’ unions in particular to fight that battle.  And they are too dependent on a vision of victimhood to risk telling young blacks that they have to get their own act together too.”  I love this thought because it states the obvious to me.  While all Americans need to work together to find solutions to our national problems, young black men and women must exercise some personal responsibility to eliminate any gaps (actual or perceived) between the races. 

If you haven’t read any of his books, I encourage you to do so.  I particularly recommend one of his most recent, “Discrimination and Disparities” or his “Controversial Essays, both of which I have read.  While the latter was written back in 2002, it demonstrates how things just don’t change – the issues or the real, thoughtful solutions to those issues.  And if you have the urge to tear down some statue, somewhere, I would prefer you erect one to this exceptional man in the place of your choosing!!

7 comments:

  1. Vouchers are virtually meaningless outside the cities unless you're expecting more kids to go virtual, and as currently constructed, only leave the most at-risk students behind.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Matt,
      You are disagreeing with a stone-cold genius and a black man. Do so at your own risk : - )

      Our public schools don't care about our children and they are failing them year after year and we as a country continue to fall in world rankings. And now we have the NEA vowing to teach young white children that they are evil simply because of the color of their skin, and young black children that they are victims. Those are terrible messages for everyone.

      If we had vouchers this year, I think we would see a 20% exodus from the public school system and to private schools, and many of the families leaving would be black and hispanic. This would actually improve the public schools as they woke up and began to compete. The monopoly would be over.

      As you and I have discussed, we could also include a transportation plan to be part of this move that would eliminate that barrier to poor and or minority kids.

      We could put a total plan together that would address all of these issues, but doing nothing is not the answer.

      Delete
    2. He's very smart and a wonderful writer, but that doesn't make him correct on all things.

      Vouchers as presently proposed simply exacerbate the gap between the haves and have nots. And in Arkansas, outside of Little Rock, it's really not relevant.

      To make the blanket statement "our schools don't care about our children" is just silly. Schools in affluent communities are generally very good, and in poorer places kids struggle more. Was ever thus.

      If you had vouchers this year, you wouldn't see much exodus at all unless you're saying to virtual school, and even then you wouldn't see 20%, especially in Arkansas. The private schools don't have the physical plants to take the kids.

      Saying that public schools would "wake up and begin to compete" is nuts. The public school must take all comers. It doesn't get to cherry pick like the privates. To use a basketball analogy, it's like thinking you're going to win if you have to take the first 4 people who walk in the gym, while your opponent gets to grab the best 4 players in the area.

      Again, all of this is really not an issue in Arkansas except in Little Rock, or unless you're talking virtual schools. But in Little Rock, were you do vouchers now, the most at risk kids would suffer even more than they already do.

      Delete
  2. Good article! I Love Thomas Sowell, and believe wholeheartedly in School Choice (Vouchers and Charter Schools). This is the Battleground for America. We can’t allow another generation to be sacrificed on the alter to Marxist/Secular Humanism. Abortion and Public Schools are destroying the soul of America. Please keep writing and speaking God’s Truth! Be Blessed! Bob

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have listened to several discussions by Thomas Sowell on the issues of race, slavery, etc... I found a profound and though provoking statement of his which bares consideration, "What is peculiar in Western Society is not that it had slaves like the other societies around the world but that it was the first civilization to turn away from it." No excuses, no justification, simple historical fact: what caused after thousands of years of slavery across every continent and every culture and in every nation...the Western Culture to turn away from slavery? When China was the "largest most comprehensive market for the exchange of human beings" and India had "more slaves than than all the people in the western hemisphere", and "pirates in Europe had trafficked and sold >1 million slaves to the coast of north africa"...what caused our nation to turn its back on slavery? What was the seed? What was the impetus? Did it come from Darwinism? Did it come from atheism? Did it come from scientific data? Which worldview produced the powerful and all encompassing statement that ALL men and women, child to adult, are created equal and are gifted by their Creator with unalienable rights? Slavery sadly still exists in this world. Human Trafficking continues to be epidemic. The devaluation of human life persists from the womb to the elderly. Which worldview devalues the sacredness and intrinsic value of life? Can Mordecai Karl Marx solve the evil in the world when he is capable of penning words like his poem "Human Pride": "With disdain I will throw my gauntlet, Full in the face of the world, And see the collapse of this pygmy giant, Whose fall will not stifle my ardour, Then will I wander godlike and victorious, Through the ruins of the world, And, giving my words an active force, I will feel equal to the Creator." Who is the demigod now when Bakunin writes in his 1924 work titled "Works": "One has to worship Marx in order to be loved by him. One has to fear him in order to be tolerated by him. Marx is extremely proud, up to dirt and madness." Should we be following a man whose ideas has resulted in the oppression of nations and the gratuitous murdering of countless millions? Even Lenin on his deathbed said, "I have committed a great error. My nightmare is to have the feeling that I'm lost in an ocean of blood from the innumerable victims. It is to late to return. To save our country, Russia, we would have needed men like Francis of Assisi..." Thomas Sowell is a breath of fresh air in a world of nonsense. We need to heed the voices of reason and understand that ideas once believed form character. Character will drive thoughts; thoughts will determine words and actions; words and actions once recorded form history. Never truer words were ever penned: as a person thinks in his heart, so is he... Ideas and words are not neutral nor harmless, they have consequences.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wow! Here is a comment that may be better than the original. It is at least a fantastic addendum.

      Delete
  4. He is a great American Kevin. Great post / article as usual.

    ReplyDelete